Friday, August 12, 2011

2011 Topps Allen & Ginter Baseball Box Break Recap and Review

Collectors love Allen & Ginter.  There is something about the set that keeps them coming back, year after year.   No wonder the 2010 Sports Card Award for Fan Favorite Set of the Year went to Allen & Ginter.  There have been some small changes made to the 2011 release, which can be a good thing or a bad thing.  In this case the changes worked out well.

2011 Topps Allen & Ginter Baseball is definitely for set builder.  Ginter falls under our classification of trading cards.  A&G is available in a variety of retail configurations and in hobby boxes that contain 24 packs with 8 cards per pack.  Each hobby box yields three hits that include autograph cards, relic cards, printing plates, rip cards or book cards.

Here are some of the cards we found in our box.

First, the new look base cards
Jorge Posada

To see the changes to this year's release, here are Jorge Posada's card from 2010 and 2011.

It is clear what has changed.  But when you look at the backs of these cards...

you can see not much has been done differently here.  Here are some of the best base card pulls.

Clayton Kershaw, Ryan Braun, Neftali Feliz, Jonathan Broxton, Robinson Cano
Brian McCann, Adrian Gonzalas, Mickey Mantle, Starlin Castro, Chone Figgins
Ryan Howard, Chipper Jones, Ervin Santana, Brandon Belt, Aaron Hill

Michael Pineda, Alex Rodriguez, Buster Posey, Tommy Hanson, Brian Wilson
Marlon Byrd, Tim Lincecum, Adam Dunn (not his year), Todd Helton, Freddie Freeman
Josh Beckett, Chase Utley, Pablo Sandoval, Heath Bell, Carlos Gonzalez

Prince Fielder, Roy Halladay
Cliff Lee, Paul Konerko

And, of course, there is a variety of famous people from other sports and walks of life.

Nancy Lopez, Picabo Street, Chuck Woolery, L.L. Zamenhof
Matt Guy, Ana Julaton, Nickolay Shmyrev, Diana Taurasi
Jim Nantz, Manny Pacquiao, Hope Solo, Rudy Ruettiger

The base set is paralleled in mini versions.

This is Evan Lysacek in Mini and Base card versions.  Here are the backs of the cards.

Same information on both.  Some of the inserts for the set only com in mini size.

Animals in Peril
Uninvited Guests, Step Right Up, World's Most Mysterious Figures, Penultimacy
Short Print Black Border, and then 4 regular minis, Lysacek, Ichiro, Tim Hudson, Ryan Howard 

Regular size inserts include...

 Floating Fortresses

 Baseball Highlight Sketches

 Minds That Made

 The Ascent of Man

Hometown Heroes

Crack the Code, a contest imbedded in the card set, returns, but this year is tied into a twitter account for additional clues.

 Here are some crack the code cards.  Look carefully!

Part of the code is included on these versions of the base cards.

And now for our three hits from the box.

 Jersey Relic Cards of Xavier Nady, Shane Victorino and Melky Cabrera
These are mini cards encased regular card sized housings.

Here are the backs of the cards.  There is room for them to move, these are not off-centered settings.

Overall Look
The design departs a little from the classic look of the Allen & Ginter cards of 1880, the set on which these cards were originally based.  Adding team logos, changes to bordering and color scheme work well, but no question the cards have a different feel from past years releases.  But most inserts feel consistent with past Ginter cards.

Quality and Variety of Players and Subsets.
This is certainly the most variety you will find in any set, which is why collectors love it.  In the same pack of cards you can pull an Ichiro, Stan Lee, Wee Man, Rasputin, Florence Nightingale and Flatworms.  Variety is what this set is about.  The Hometown Heroes are a really nice set of inserts.

Do the hits hold up?
There is a deep checklist for the relic cards that come in jersey and bat varieties.  They can be found at a rate of 1 in every 10 packs.  For comparison, most of the specialty minis are harder to pull, at a rate of 1 in every 12 packs.  The hits are nicely designed.  Mini Autos, rip cards an booklets are the prized hits here but a tough pull.

Will you want to collect them all?
Allen and Ginter has always been kind of a mixed bag, going all the way back to the original 1880 release.  Most love it.  It is not uncommon to chase the master set on this one.  But even those who are not as inspired by Ginter will probably collect a little of it in private, picking up their favorites, making sure not to let on about their guilty pleasure. 

4 out of 5

2011 Topps Allen & Ginter Baseball provides the most variety out there for set builders.

Review box provided by Topps


  1. Those have got to be the worst three "hits" ever assembled in one box. If one buys a box for the "hits" one might be screaming bloody murder with a box like this. Brutal.

  2. Does that Wright black boarder happen to be for trade?